Is AI Making Us Smarter?

Is AI Making Us Smarter?

Rethinking Intelligence in the Era of AI-Driven Technology

Firefly Abstract icon-is-ai-making-us-smarter-blog-main-img

Image generated by Adobe Firefly for Van E. Eiseman

Recently, a friend challenged me with a pointed question: "Is AI making us smarter?" Their position was an emphatic "no." They argued that our smartphones have become memory crutches—we no longer remember phone numbers, addresses, or important dates. In their view, digital technology is enabling us to think less.

I understood their perspective. I'll admit I don't know my children's phone numbers by heart, though I remember my wife's—a number unchanged for the past 27 years of being together. But this exchange sparked a deeper reflection: Have we confused memorization with intelligence?

Beyond Memorization

Growing up, many of us had encyclopedia sets in our homes—impressive volumes of knowledge sitting on bookshelves waiting to enlighten young minds. But how many of us actually read them cover to cover? I certainly didn't. Was I less intelligent at 16 because I hadn't absorbed those 25 leather-bound books?

Today, I carry access to exponentially more information than those encyclopedias contained in my pocket. This isn't just a quantitative change—it's a qualitative transformation in how we engage with knowledge.

Is intelligence defined by what we can recall, or by what we can access, synthesize, and apply?


The Evolution of Intelligence

Throughout history, every major information technology has shifted the boundary between what humans needed to remember and what they could access externally. The origin of written language allowed us to store information outside our brains. The printing press democratized that storage. Computers expanded it exponentially.

With each shift, what constituted "intelligence" evolved. When information was scarce, memorization was indeed valuable. But in an era of information abundance, different cognitive skills take precedence: critical thinking, pattern recognition, creative synthesis, and ethical reasoning.

These aren't entirely new capabilities—they've always been valuable. But their importance relative to memorization has dramatically increased.

The Global Intelligence Equation

Perhaps the most profound implication of our current technological era lies in its democratizing potential. Within the next decade, over a billion new users will come online. They'll gain unprecedented access to the world's information—not in encyclopedias requiring literacy in specific languages, but through increasingly intuitive interfaces that adapt to human needs.

I recently built a chatbot without programming it in multiple languages. However, when users interact with it in Spanish, French, German, or combinations of all three, it understands and responds appropriately. It even asks which language they prefer. Beyond just convenience, it's a fundamental shift in accessing global knowledge.

Is someone less intelligent because they don't speak multiple languages? Or are we collectively more intelligent when technology bridges these divides?

Amplifying Intelligence

The emerging era of AI-driven technology is more about technology amplifying human intelligence than replacing it. When AI handles routine memory tasks and information retrieval, our cognitive resources are freed for what humans do best: making unexpected connections, applying contextual judgment, and engaging with emotional and ethical dimensions that algorithms can't fully grasp.

True intelligence in this new technological landscape emerges from the partnership between human cognition and technological capability. It's not an either/or proposition, but a fundamentally new synthesis.

The most intelligent people I know aren't those who memorize the most facts—they're those who ask the most insightful questions, who connect seemingly unrelated concepts, and who apply knowledge thoughtfully to complex problems.

Redefining What Makes Us Smart

As we navigate this transformation, we shouldn't measure intelligence by industrial-era standards. The ability to recall specific information will matter less than the ability to construct meaningful queries, to critically evaluate sources, to synthesize insights across domains, and to apply knowledge ethically.

When technology serves humanity, as it should in this new era of anticipatory technology, it extends our intelligence in dimensions never before possible. It allows us to focus our uniquely human capabilities on higher-order challenges while seamlessly supporting our cognitive limitations.

So, is AI making us smarter? If we define "smart" as memorizing information that's readily available, perhaps not. But if we understand intelligence as our capacity to engage meaningfully with complex problems, to connect disparate ideas, to create and innovate—then yes, I believe it is.

The smartphone in your pocket isn't making you dumber. It's expanding the definition of what being smart can mean—if we're thoughtful about how we use it.